The 20-year outcome of the Charnley arthroplasty in younger and older patients

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to present the 20-year outcome of 206 Charnley low-friction arthroplasties done by the same surgeon on 181 patients who were separated into two age groups (younger and older). In Group A (76 patients, 92 hips) the mean age at surgery, was 44 years (range, 24-55 years), and in Group B (105 patients, 114 hips) the mean age at surgery was 65 years (range, 56-82 years). All patients were evaluated clinically and radiographically. At final followup, 71 patients (87 hips) in Group A and 90 patients (99 hips) in Group B were available for study. The overall failure rate for the hips of Group A was 37.9%, and the overall failure rate for the hips of Group B was 20%. The main cause of failure in Group A was aseptic loosening of the components and breakage of the femoral stem, whereas in Group B the main cause of failure was deep infection. We concluded that by eliminating the above factors, and using new cementing techniques and improved implants, the 20-year results of this arthroplasty would be better. Our results show that the Charnley arthroplasty is a reliable procedure for hip replacement, even in younger patients.